
Before we get started this week, a quick shameless ad:
If you're enjoying this newsletter then check out my book, Startup Different, which goes deeper on a lot of the business topics I cover here. You can find it on Amazon, Audible and Kindle.
And now, onto this week's newsletter.

Everyone is trying to figure out how AI fits into their business, and most of the conversation is centered around replacing people.
It’s an understandable instinct… AI can analyze data, summarize information, and automate workflows faster and cheaper than ever before.
But that framing misses what’s actually happening.
The shift we’re going to see (and already are) is repositioning humans into more of an “overseer” role.
And in many cases, the right humans are becoming more valuable, not less.
AI Gets You Most of the Way There
AI is incredibly effective at getting you to a strong starting point.
The part where decisions are made, and consequences actually matter, still depends heavily on human judgment.
That last portion of the work is where the real value lives, and it’s also where AI tends to fall short.
Where AI Still Struggles
AI performs best when it can rely on patterns it has already seen, but businesses rarely operate in predictable environments.
There are always edge cases, exceptions, and situations that require context.
It can approximate nuance, but it doesn’t truly understand it (yet). Tone, timing, relationships, and risk all require interpretation, not just pattern recognition.
More importantly, AI doesn’t take responsibility for outcomes. It can generate an answer, but it doesn’t deal with the consequences if that answer is wrong.
That responsibility still sits with people.
The Rise of the “Human in the Loop”
This is why the idea of the “human in the loop” is becoming so important. The role of humans is shifting away from pure execution and toward oversight, refinement, and decision-making.
Instead of doing every step manually, the human becomes the one who reviews outputs, applies context, and decides what actually moves forward.
Execution is becoming easier to automate, but knowing what is correct, useful, and safe is not.
Why Oversight Is Now the Bottleneck
As AI continues to improve, execution is getting cheaper. Tools can write, analyze, and generate faster than ever before.
But the ability to evaluate those outputs and make sound decisions is becoming the constraint.
The companies that recognize this are not trying to remove humans entirely. They are being more intentional about where humans sit within their workflows.
They keep people involved at key decision points, especially where nuance or risk is involved, and they build review layers into their processes so that AI outputs are checked before they reach customers or influence important decisions.
The Trap of Full Automation
There is a growing push toward fully automated systems because they appear efficient and scalable. In practice, they often introduce fragility.
When everything is automated, small errors can scale quickly, and there is no one actively catching them. Removing the human doesn’t eliminate risk. In many cases, it amplifies it.
This is where many companies are making mistakes right now.
They focus on how much they can automate rather than where human oversight is still necessary, and the result is a system that looks efficient on paper but becomes brittle in reality.
What Smart Companies Are Doing Differently
The companies getting this right are not avoiding AI. They are simply more thoughtful about how they use it.
They keep humans at key decision points, ensure that important outputs are reviewed before being acted on, and hire for judgment rather than just execution.
They also recognize that fully removing humans is not the goal. The goal is to combine the speed of AI with the judgment of experienced operators.
With so many firms going "all in" on AI, having a human touch with systems or customers at the right time can counterintuitively become a competitive advantage.
AI is changing how work gets done, but it is not eliminating the need for people. It is concentrating value into a different type of role.
As execution becomes more accessible and outputs become easier to generate, the real advantage shifts to those who can apply context, make good decisions, and manage risk effectively.
The companies that win in this environment will be the ones who understand where humans matter most and design their systems accordingly.
Because in an AI-driven world, good judgment is not being replaced. It is becoming more valuable.
Thanks for reading!
Dave


